Mystery Box (4 Homemade Cookies)
$45.00
A fun mystery box featuring 4 freshly baked cookies in a mix of our most-loved flavors and seasonal creations—perfect for trying something new with every bite. Choose nut-free or no preference.
COOKIE FAQs
Are your cookies nut-free or allergy-friendly?
Some of our cookies may contain nuts or other allergens. Please check individual cookie descriptions for details.
Our kitchen handles peanuts, tree nuts, dairy, eggs, wheat, and soy. While we take great care to minimize cross-contamination and follow best practices, we are not an allergy-free bakery. Customers with severe allergies should use their best judgment before ordering.
Do you ship your cookies?
Yes! We have created special packaging to ship our cookies directly to your home anywhere in the USA.
To maintain the freshest quality, orders are shipped twice weekly.
Shipping Days:
- Monday
- Thursday
Order Cutoff Times:
- Orders placed by Sunday 10:00 PM ship Monday
- Orders placed by Wednesday 10:00 PM ship Thursday
Orders placed after cutoff will ship on the next available shipping day.
All shipments use USPS Ground Advantage, with tracking provided at dispatch. Delivery typically takes 3–5 business days depending on your location.
Do you offer local delivery or pickup?
Local orders (Sarasota & Lakewood Ranch) are delivered directly to your door twice weekly.
Delivery Days:
- Monday
- Thursday
Delivery Window:
- 4:00 PM – 9:00 PM
Order Cutoff Times:
- Orders placed by Sunday 10:00 PM deliver Monday
- Orders placed by Wednesday 10:00 PM deliver Thursday
Orders after cutoff will be scheduled for the next delivery day.
Catering & Event Orders
Place your catering or event order at least 4 days prior to your event. Your order is delivered on a custom date and time based on your event needs